Sleepless in Ottawa

FamilyTreeDNA (FTDNA) had the nerve to email me that my cousin L’s mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) results were ready. At midnight!

What did I do? I got out of bed, logged in to his kit, and was still looking at ALL OF IT at 7 a.m.

Most of his results were available. Sure enough, he matched me. He matched my closest mtDNA matches, too. His Mitotree haplogroup wasn’t showing yet, nor was his subclade, but his legacy haplogroup was right on target.

Still awake at 7AM

So if everything fell into place, why was I still up at seven? Because the match was the part I expected. It was the questions I couldn’t answer that kept me awake.

  • What can L’s results, alongside mine, tell us about how we might connect to our closest mtDNA matches?
  • Can we trace our lines back to the families Paul Nick Hall and his sisters documented and I confirmed?
  • When I weigh the autosomal DNA matches alongside their findings and my own research, can I build a case that meets the Genealogical Proof Standard (GPS) for my direct maternal line in the Blue Ridge Mountains of the southern Appalachians?

What I had by morning

My sleepless night in Ottawa didn’t yield answers. It did, however, give me a research plan:

  • Follow up on clues that might connect my matches’ earliest known maternal ancestors to mine.
  • Identify gaps in the paper trail where DNA might be the only evidence I have to work with.
  • Figure out what evidence I’d need to test—and possibly disprove—long-held family lore.
  • Use this blog to show my DNA matches where the genetic evidence complements the paper trail and where the two tell different stories.

One question runs through all of it: How do you confirm or rule out a proposed family relationship when there’s no surviving record that names it? Adoption and unexpected parentage figure prominently in my research plan, too.

And then there’s the matter of everyone up in those hollers being named after a circuit preacher named Humphrey Posey.

I mean EVERYONE.


FamilyTreeDNA is having a sale – right now. If you have a mothers line in the mountains of Georgia, South Carolina, Tennessee and or North Carolina? Please test your mtDNA and join the Appalachian mtDNA Project.

This post may have been reviewed for grammar and spelling errors using Perplexity AI.

Five generations of maternal-line portraits for a post on mtDNA test results, set against the Blue Ridge Mountains

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top